How to Judge Your Own Progress
On measurement, meaning, and the metrics that actually matter
You’ve been working on yourself for two years now. Reading the books, doing the practices, showing up consistently to whatever version of growth you’ve committed to pursuing. Some days you feel transformed. Other days you feel like you’re exactly who you’ve always been, just with better vocabulary for your limitations.
The question emerges with increasing urgency: are you actually getting anywhere, or are you just moving in circles at a higher altitude?
You look for evidence. You’ve read forty books on psychology and philosophy. You meditate most mornings. You journal regularly. You’ve had insights that felt revolutionary in the moment. You understand concepts about human nature that you didn’t understand before.
But understanding isn’t the same as transformation. Knowledge isn’t wisdom. And you can’t shake the suspicion that you might be collecting insights the way some people collect stamps, admiring them without actually being changed by them.
How do you know if you’re actually progressing or just becoming more sophisticated in your self-deception?
This question keeps you awake some nights. Because if you’re not progressing, then what have you been doing? If all this effort hasn’t changed anything fundamental, then you’ve been performing growth rather than experiencing it. You’ve been a tourist in your own development, taking pictures of insights without living in them.
The stakes feel impossibly high. You can’t afford to be wrong about whether you’re changing because being wrong means you’ve wasted years on a project that was never actually happening. But you also can’t trust your own assessment because the very thing you’re trying to assess is your capacity for accurate self-perception.
Most people judge their progress by how they feel. If they feel more confident, they assume they’re progressing. If they feel anxious or uncertain, they assume they’re regressing. But feelings are terrible measures of development because they fluctuate based on sleep, blood sugar, recent events, and a thousand other variables that have nothing to do with actual growth.
You can be making tremendous progress while feeling terrible because growth often feels like confusion, uncertainty, and the discomfort of outgrowing old patterns. You can be completely stagnant while feeling great because familiar patterns feel comfortable even when they’re limiting you.
Seneca watched his students make this mistake constantly. They would attend his lectures, nod enthusiastically, report feeling inspired and transformed, then return to their lives completely unchanged. The emotional experience of learning felt like progress, but no actual development was occurring. They were mistaking stimulation for transformation, the high of insight for the hard work of integration.
He knew this because he’d done it himself. He’d felt transformed by philosophical ideas only to discover he still responded to criticism with defensiveness, to loss with despair, to difficulty with avoidance. The gap between understanding and embodiment was vast, and feeling like you’d crossed it meant nothing about whether you actually had.
The mind must be tested in situations where its quality can be revealed.
Not by how many ideas you’ve absorbed, but by how you actually behave when tested. Not by what you understand intellectually, but by what you demonstrate practically.
This is the measure that destroys most people’s self-assessment. Because by this standard, your progress isn’t measured by how much you’ve learned or how many insights you’ve had. It’s measured by whether you respond differently to situations that used to overwhelm you.
Do you still react with the same defensiveness when criticized? Do you still avoid the same uncomfortable conversations? Do you still make decisions from the same fears? Do you still sacrifice your wellbeing for others’ approval in the same ways?
If the answer is yes, then whatever progress you’ve made exists only in theory. You’ve upgraded your understanding without upgrading your behavior, which is like downloading new software but never installing it. You walk around with all this potential transformation stored in your mind, never actually running it when situations demand it.
And this realization, when it comes, feels devastating. All those books, all those practices, all that effort, and you’re still reacting the same way to the same triggers. Still avoiding the same conversations. Still choosing safety over authenticity in the same moments. Still being ruled by the same fears you’ve supposedly been transcending.
But here’s the trap within the trap: genuine progress often looks like regression from the inside.
Over 160,000 people now read Stoic Wisdoms, with hundreds of paying subscribers applying these lessons daily. If you haven’t upgraded yet, you can unlock this full post and all Premium content including the Confidence series & Stoic Reflections.
NEW YEAR SALE! Annual subscriptions are 50% off until January 1. If you want full access and all upcoming releases, now is the best time to join!