How to Actually Change
Why transformation requires more than understanding what needs to transform
In Knowing and Not Acting we explored the suffering that comes from understanding exactly what needs to change while remaining frozen at the threshold of change. We examined why knowledge so often fails to produce action, why the gap between knowing and doing becomes a source of its own pain. That essay diagnosed the problem. This one explores what happens when you actually try to cross that threshold.
There’s a moment that comes to everyone who’s ever attempted real change. Usually around day three.
You’ve made the decision. You understand why it matters. You’ve committed to the new behavior. And then you wake up on day three and the entire project feels absurd. The old way suddenly seems reasonable, even preferable. The new behavior feels like you’re wearing someone else’s clothes. Every cell in your body is suggesting you return to what you know.
Most people interpret this moment as failure. They think: “This isn’t working. This isn’t me. Maybe I’m not ready for this change.” They abandon the attempt and conclude that transformation isn’t for them.
But what if that moment is the change? What if the feeling of everything being wrong is exactly what becoming different feels like from the inside?
We discussed in Knowing and Not Acting how we accumulate sophisticated knowledge about what should change while remaining behaviorally unchanged. The weight of unlived knowledge, we called it. Information possessed but not embodied. Understanding achieved but not practiced.
The question we didn’t fully address was: what do you actually do with that weight? How do you convert dormant knowledge into lived reality? How do you bridge the gap between the person who knows what should be different and the person who lives differently?
The answer sounds simple until you try it: you do the thing while it still feels completely wrong.
This violates everything we’ve been taught about authenticity and self-alignment. We’re told change should feel natural, that if you’re forcing it, you’re doing it wrong. We’re encouraged to “honor our truth,” to “listen to our authentic self,” to wait until new behaviors feel right before implementing them.
But your authentic self is currently the person avoiding change. Your truth is currently structured around maintaining the status quo. Waiting for new behaviors to feel natural before doing them guarantees they’ll never feel natural because the only way they become natural is through doing them.
Over 170,000 people now read Stoic Wisdoms, with hundreds of paying subscribers applying these lessons daily. If you haven’t upgraded yet, you can unlock this full post and all Premium content including the Confidence series & Stoic Reflections.